Here’s where I fall out with all the dog training class people.
I have no doubt that there are a lot of dedicated dog trainers who attend seminars and courses to expand their knowledge and spend lots of time and effort running training classes with the best intentions at heart.
I constantly get asked to look at dogs displaying acts of aggression, protectiveness or possessiveness. A good percentage of these dogs have been to dog training and puppy socialisation classes. I constantly get the line “we took him to dog training classes but he still doesn’t do what he’s told”. Another classic line I get is “He’s done his good citizens award but he’s not really that obedient”
So lets be honest about all this training class lark. How come a good number of people come through dog training classes and still have a disobedient dog? How come the good citizens award scheme gives the impression that the dogs have been trained and can operate to a level of obedience when in reality these certificates have been known to be awarded at some champ shows “willy nilly”.
Dogs need routines that are fun but incorporate obedience and pack rules.
I attended a dog training class with my 2 dogs. My initial reason for attending the class was to socialise them with other dogs. Oscar was just not suited to the training class environment plus there were aggressive dogs that were being not being addressed and and were being permitted to give out some truly aggressive signals. The class ended up having a negative effect on Oscar making him more stressed in the company of other dogs than he had been previously. I ended up pulling him out and training him to focus on me in the company of other male dogs using a clicker.
Lu was a model student but to be honest by that time I just could not hack the monotonous methods that were being preached so I pulled her out also. For some reason it appears to take ages to teach a dog to do simple tasks like heal, sit, down and stay in the training class environment. I wonder if this is financially motivated?
Here’s my beef about training classes.
- Training classes place dogs in an artificial environment. This environment prevents dogs from sorting out their own hierarchy. I find collies and other sight based beeds particularly guilty of inciting aggression by constantly eying up other dogs in the class. This is the situation that can cause stress and end up in a violent outburst. These types of issues would be sorted quickly with a sniff or at worst a short squabble in a natural environment
- I can normally clicker train most dogs to heel, sit and wait easily within 15 – 30 minutes. Yes I admit that the owner needs to perfect and maintain the behaviour but the initial instruction to the dog takes virtually no time. Why do owners have to attend 8 hours or more of training classes to get their dog to perform these basic tasks? Incidentally these basic tasks are more often than not performed inconsistently because the onus is placed on the dog NOT the owner.
- Training classes have this thing about banishing noisy or aggressive dogs out of the room or into a corner. This is a behavioural trick that doesnt work very well in a class situation. My opinion is that a dog who is displaying a protection, fear or dominant instinct needs to be addressed in a one to one situation to ensure that the dog understands why he is not being included in the pack activity. I'm not in favour of just ignoring or banishing the dog hoping that the problem will go away.
- My old rant – Dog trainers train using language based commands that require the dog to interpret and work out what is required. I prefer to communicate with dogs using body language. I train a behaviour without the use of verbal communication then associate a command to the behaviour when it has been firmly established.
- Training classes attempt to teach dogs to respond to commands. I tend to teach owners how to communicate with their dogs rather than expect the dogs to interpret human commands. I spend time one to one with owners to ensure they understand what I’m teaching. I’m normally available for backup consultations or advice via phone or email and I attempt to teach owners how to motivate their dogs by building drive and focus. I try to make training sessions fun. I also encourage and advise on routines that test and reinforce all the basic commands on a daily basis.
- Some trainers use the classes as a platform to promote themselves. I call it canine cabaret. Others use it as a platform to promote their canine related businesses like dog food distribution or dog walking services.
- I must say I see a lot of training classes being run with a view of generating income. Like it or not these classes can be big business with some taking place 2 or 3 times a week with classes of 25 or more. I’m in the fortunate position where I can treat the finance side of my work as secondary. I’m genuinely in this for the dogs and all my clients will back me up on this one – my main concern is keeping dogs out of the never ending rescue centre cycle.
Summary
Training classes will not suit every dog or every owner. I find a lot of high drive dogs paricularly the herding and guarding breeds get uptight and frustrated in these classes.
The object of a training class is to provide mass production obedience. A Training classes is a good vehicle to communicate techniques to a large audience but these techniques are sometimes received out of context. This is not always the fault of the trainer , more a consequence of mass information transfer. I find that dogs pick things up much faster than humans and time needs to be taken to ensure that owners understand what is required.
Training classes do little to address behavioural problems. I’ve rarely heard anything mentioned about pack status, group dynamics or solid leadership techniques in a training class. My advice is to get the pack order and behavioural issues in place and the training will look after itself.
New dog owners seldom learn how to make a dog tick by attending training classes. Dogs need to be motivated and owners have to learn how to be interesting.
Dogs need routines that incorporate high activity, obedience, fun, grooming, bonding and everything that is fulfilling.
I'm not knocking dog training classes but I genuinely think they are for a limited audience and have a restricted content.






